The best books that re-imagine outsiders and villains

I became enthralled by Claudius through the TV drama starring Derek Jacobi, but later came to the novels.

A stammering, reclusive young man dismissed as a fool, the bookish Claudius is all of us who watch from the wings, hoping not to draw attention to ourselves. He manages to outlive others, including Tacitus and Caligula, to succeed to the imperial purple.

Graves is a noted historian who drew on Plutarch, Suetonius, and Tacitus for his portrayal. His books on ancient cultures and religions were among many that I devoured in my research.

I’ve been deeply engaged in questions of women’s spirituality, including the accusations of witchcraft leveled at healers, psychics, and just plain unpopular women.

The witch in question is Janet Horne, whose execution in 1727 marked the last witchcraft trial and judicial killing in Britain. The harrowing story of this woman and her daughter, set in Dornoch in far northeastern Scotland, provides the basis for Paris’s heartfelt novel.

I was taken by his use of a traveling group of entertainers as a major element in the story of prejudice and malice. Just this year, an official tartan was released, commemorating the hundreds who lost their lives. The pattern is predominantly black, with red for the tape on legal documents and gray denoting ash.

I’ve loved Margaret Atwood for so long! The Edible Woman came first, then The Handmaid’s Tale, Cat’s Eye, her poems, her writing on writing–yet this is another book that I came to as a result of a televised drama.

In mid-19th-century Canada, two servants were charged with murdering a man and his housekeeper. I was hooked by Atwood’s many-layered depiction of the female villain, Grace Marks. She approaches the story through a fictional doctor doing research about criminals who struggles to match up the bloody-handed murderer with the subservient servant. 

I had the great pleasure of studying with Jane Alison during my MFA at Queens University of Charlotte, and so as a diligent student, I, of course, read her books. As a poet as well as a novelist, I was captivated by the lyricism in this depiction of the Roman poet who gave us the Metamorphoses.

A different twist on historical retelling, this book is based on Ovid’s banishment to a miserable backwater far from his beloved Rome and his encounter with a fictional Black Sea enchantress. Alison built an incredible character in Xenia, a woman of power, a muse, and maybe Ovid’s match. 

Among the many detective shows, I’ve loved “Murdoch Mysteries” for its cheeky take on Canadian history and policing. You’ll find that this story collection for Young Adult readers takes a similar approach.

The fictional detective is shown in his youth, already solving mysteries and interacting with both famous fictional villains and historical figures. I read many of these stories–nearly all published in Black Cat Weekly–in manuscript, returning the favor as Sirois is a writing friend, a longtime beta reader, and even designed a cover for one of my novels.