Will I love The Poppy War?

This book is written with razor-sharp prose that's as immersive as it is devastating. Every page carries with it tension and purpose, making it impossible to put down. While it did drag a little in the middle for me, the beginning and ending of the book made this a 5-star read for me. The characters are complex and constantly evolving, blurring the line between right and wrong in the most compelling way. This book is a masterclass in storytelling that grips you from the first word to the last.

I picked this up expecting a revenge fantasy story based on what I’d heard, but what I got was something far more brutal.

Much like my #3 pick, this story doesn’t flinch. It dissects power, identity, and the cost of survival with narrative precision. Watching Rin’s descent was nearly voyeuristic; it felt wrong, but you couldn’t help but watch.

This book is an excellent example of fantasy that doesn’t need to pull its punches. It can confront uncomfortable topics head-on and still leaves room for humanity and consequences.

The Poppy War was a surprise for me. I picked it up on a whim in the bookstore and it was in my TBR shelf for a while. When I started reading it, I couldn't put it down. I It was well written and Ran is a fabulous, take no crap, strong female main character (which I absolutely love). Honestly I loved her story arc, the fights and powers. It is just one of those books that seemed to be written specifically for me lol.

When I first started reading this book, I thought it would be like every other fantasy novel featuring an orphan who goes to an elite school for magic. How wrong I was! Unlike the other books on this list which are more or less set in our world (but with magic!) The Poppy War is actually a secondary world fantasy.

What warrants its place on the list (besides being very good) is the fact that the plot points mirror the events of World War II, specifically the fighting between Japan and China.

This book is not for the faint of… show more.

I have enjoyed Kuang’s books—her careful research into every topic with protagonists who struggle to fit in and experience mistreatment. The characters are relatable, and while the technology and magic add uniqueness, it is really a story about humans. Like her other novels, this one is an imaginative “alternative history” involving science and magic.

Set in China’s often inhuman activities of the 20th century, the protagonist is a young peasant girl sent to a military academy. There, she experiences mistreatment because of her skin color and low social status, but she has the magical skills of a shaman. (Kuang implies… show more.

I loved the characterisation of all the players in the novel, especially the protagonist, Rin, who had a sarky wit. The writing was full of action and humour but also somber when it needed to be such as the scenes of massacre and war crimes.

The book taught me a lot about the Sino-Japanese war which appeals to me as I am fascinated by oriental history especially China and Japan. I was born in Singapore of mixed race – Indian, Iranian and Chinese heritage, raised by a Chinese grandmother and mother. The book helped me connect to my Chinese roots.

The Poppy War is an epic, grim military fantasy inspired by the Sino-Japanese wars. Rin, a war orphan from the southern Rooster Provinces, aces the Empire-wide admittance exam to Sinegard–the premier military academy in Nikan. But as a dark-skinned peasant from a rural province, Rin’s struggles only compound as she fights for acceptance among her aristocratic peers. And when the fragile peace with Mugen is broken, Rin discovers her greatest powers come at even greater costs. 

I adore how The Poppy War combines the very best of the fantasy academia genre with military fantasy. Add in some heavy historical allegories,… show more.

At first, The Poppy War seems like an edgier version of Harry Potter: an outcast-at-the-academy story with a slightly older protagonist, drugs, and a few incidents of self-harm. Then the book veers into Hell.

The setting has a lot to do with it. The Poppy War takes place in a fantasy version of 20th-century China; the eventual focus is a magic-infused retelling of the Second Sino-Japanese War, which included a slaughter sometimes referred to as the “Forgotten Holocaust.”

So, yeah: not a bedtime story to enjoy with your kids. I also wouldn’t start The Poppy War if you’re not in… show more.

The first book in a celebrated trilogy by R.F. Kuang, The Poppy War more than earns its fame with innovative worldbuilding, an absorbing and sometimes shocking plot, and beautifully concise writing. But the reason it’s on this list is the way it deals with an almost unimaginable horror, taken from our real world into the realm of fantasy in a way that neither sensationalizes nor diminishes history. I am a descendant of genocide survivors twice over, which makes Kuang’s ability to tell this kind of story especially resonant for me.