There are 8 books in the Surprised by Love series. The newest book is An Amish Second Chance Romance which came out in 2025.

1
An Unexpected Amish Proposal

Book cover of An Unexpected Amish Proposal
Sometimes love is found in the most unexpected places--as three blessed men will discover in Rachel J. Good's heartwarming Amish romance series, set in a bustling Pennsylvania community...

When an organic farm causes rents to skyrocket at the Valley Green Farmer's Market, Fern Blauch's family baked goods stand is driven

When you buy books, we may earn a commission that helps keep our lights on (or join the rebellion as a member).

3
An Unexpected Amish Christmas

Book cover of An Unexpected Amish Christmas
In USA Today bestselling author Rachel J. Good’s new Surprised by Love Amish romance, two lonely pen pals—a grieving woman with too many responsibilities and a shy man paralyzed in a buggy accident—fall in love through their letters. Will the Green Valley Farmer’s Market be the unlikely backdrop for translating


4
An Amish Marriage of Convenience

Book cover of An Amish Marriage of Convenience
In Rachel J. Good’s sweetly romantic inspirational series, a bustling Green Valley Farmer’s Market in Pennsylvania is the perfect place for residents of nearby Amish communities to find the partner of their dreams—when, and how, they least expect it! Will appeal to fans of Charlotte Hubbard, Amy Lillard, and Jennifer


5
Her Pretend Amish Boyfriend

Book cover of Her Pretend Amish Boyfriend
In USA Today bestselling author Rachel J. Good's sweetly romantic inspirational series, the bustling Green Valley Farmer's Market in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania has everything your heart desires, from fresh-picked produce to oven-warm pies...and maybe even a chance to find love. Perfect for fans of Amy Clipston, Wanda E. Brunstetter, and


6
Dating an Amish Flirt

Book cover of Dating an Amish Flirt
In USA Today bestselling author Rachel J. Good's sweet inspirational romance, the bustling Green Valley Farmer's Market in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania has everything the residents of nearby Amish communities could ever need...including a chance to find love when they least expect!

Perfect for fans of Amy Clipston, Wanda E. Brunstetter,


7
Missing Her Amish Boyfriend

Book cover of Missing Her Amish Boyfriend
Savory barbecue chicken . . . golden-crisp potatoes . . . and fresh-picked produce are just a few of the offerings at Lancaster, Pennsylvania's Green Valley Farmer's Market—along with surprising opportunities to find forever friendships, comforting advice—and love's most delicious possibilities . . .

Filled with faith, community, and sweet


8
An Amish Second Chance Romance

Book cover of An Amish Second Chance Romance
From stunning handmade crafts to fresh-picked produce and mouthwatering baked goods, Lancaster, Pennsylvania's Green Valley Farmers Market offers sweet surprises every day—including the chance to make new friends, find community—and even discover a forever kind of happiness . . .

Filled with faith, community, and sweet romance, USA Today bestselling