There are 22 books in the Ettie Smith Amish Mysteries series. The newest book is Amish Mishaps and Murder which came out in 2022.

1
Secrets Come Home

Book cover of Secrets Come Home

Welcome to the world of Ettie Smith Amish Mysteries, where USA Today Bestselling author Samantha Price blends intrigue, humor, and charm in this much-loved series.
When Ettie Smith inherits her late friend Agatha's home, she stumbles upon a chilling secret: a body concealed beneath the floorboards. While the police are…

When you buy books, we may earn a commission that helps keep our lights on (or join the rebellion as a member).

2
Amish Murder

Book cover of Amish Murder

In 'Amish Murder,' an estranged Amish woman's life is brutally cut short, and suspicion falls heavily on her brother, Jacob. The town's new detective finds himself in unfamiliar territory, his inquiries within the tight-knit Amish community meeting stony silence. In this labyrinth of suspicion and secrecy, he seeks the guidance…

3
Murder in the Amish Bakery LARGE PRINT

Book cover of Murder in the Amish Bakery LARGE PRINT: An Amish Cozy Mystery

A recipe for disaster brews as Ettie stumbles upon another dead body. This time, the unfortunate victim lies sprawled on the floor of Ruth Fuller's famous bakery. All Ettie wanted was to 'rise' to the occasion and perfect her loaf, not to 'knead' into another murder mystery!
Ruth, desperate to…

4
Amish Murder Too Close

Book cover of Amish Murder Too Close
Dead people hold no conversations, but they can leave a trail of secrets.
The woman found slain outside Ettie's house might've known too much, her life snuffed out and her valuable engagement ring gone. While the authorities attribute it to a botched robbery, Ettie sees a different pattern.
An Amish…

5
Amish Quilt Shop Mystery

Book cover of Amish Quilt Shop Mystery
Bethany's dream of owning a business is 'sewn' into reality, but the joy quickly 'unravels' when her quilt store becomes a crime scene — a man lies dead amidst her precious patterns! Naturally, Ettie Smith can't resist the allure of a mystery and threads herself into the investigation.
As Ettie…

6
Amish Baby Mystery

Book cover of Amish Baby Mystery
Wrapped in the warmth of an Amish quilt and cloaked in a shroud of mystery, an abandoned baby boy lands on Ettie and Elsa-May's doorstep. As they take the child in, a letter hidden in the quilt tumbles out, begging them to protect the child and keep his presence a…

7
Betrayed

Book cover of Betrayed
When an Amish woman is savagely attacked and left for dead, the community's usual openness fades into silence. Detective Kelly, finding himself at a loss, turns to the dependable Ettie Smith to pry into the secrets of her closed-off society.
Despite an arrest, Ettie remains convinced of the accused's innocence,…

8
Amish False Witness

Book cover of Amish False Witness

When Florence Lapp's house is reduced to ashes and her firearm goes missing, she seeks refuge with her sister, Ettie. But an extended sibling sleepover isn't exactly what Ettie has in mind, prompting her to dig into the mystery—rapid-fire.
The plot thickens when Florence's missing gun resurfaces as the weapon…

9
Amish Barn Murders

Book cover of Amish Barn Murders
Barn lights or warning signals? When peculiar illumination haunts the Strongbergs' barn, the quaint Amish community is thrust into an eerie twilight zone. Even more unsettling, these nocturnal anomalies coincide with the deaths of two Amish men.
Thomas Strongberg's passing was chalked up to a tragic accident—a fall from a…

10
Amish Christmas Mystery

Book cover of Amish Christmas Mystery
This festive season, Ettie finds herself hosting an unexpected Christmas dinner featuring guests promised a meal 'to die for.'
The dinner party includes some unexpected faces like Ettie's estranged daughter, Myra, and the retired Detective Crowley. But the holiday spirit quickly 'freezes' over when a man is found lifeless in…

11
Lost

Book cover of Lost: Amish Mystery
Stumbling onto secrets or skeletons? When Ettie unearths human bones in a field, she unexpectedly finds herself implicated in a cold case murder mystery. In her quest to clear her name, Ettie crosses paths with an Amish woman, Gertie, who spins a chilling yarn of two 'accidental' deaths.
Initially, Ettie…

12
Old Promises

Book cover of Old Promises: Amish Suspense and Mystery

Unyielding in her conviction that her daughter Myra couldn't so much as squish a bug, Ettie Smith's world is sent spinning when Myra is ensnared in a murder accusation.
Teamed up with her sister, Ettie embarks on the monumental task of absolving her daughter's name, uprooting secrets that were intended…

13
Amish Mystery At Rose Cottage

Book cover of Amish Mystery At Rose Cottage

Widow Nell is consumed by an unresolved mystery from her past—Jedidiah Shoneberger, an Amish man who vanished without a trace over forty years ago, mere weeks before their wedding. Overwhelmed by a mix of grief and lingering affection, she reaches out to Ettie Smith for assistance in piecing together the…

14
Amish Mystery

Book cover of Amish Mystery: Plain Secrets
Inheriting an antiquated house from a long-lost Amish grandfather she barely knew, Selena Lehman embarks on a journey to explore her roots. But as she steps through the time-worn doors of the homestead, she stumbles upon a buried legacy that eclipses the house's crumbling state—her grandfather was a convicted murderer.…

15
Fear Thy Neighbor

Book cover of Fear Thy Neighbor: Amish Mystery
Ettie Smith had long suspected there was something peculiar about the couple next door, Stacey and Greville Charmers. After all, neighbors don't just plant petunias and borrow cups of sugar—they harbor secrets too. So when Greville meets his untimely end at the hands of an unwelcome guest, Ettie isn't just…

16
Amish Winter Murder Mystery

Book cover of Amish Winter Murder Mystery
Winter's chill grips the Amish community when the shocking news breaks—Ebenezer Fuller, found frosty and lifeless behind his barn, has been iced. Ettie Smith, not one to freeze in the face of adversity, believes she can thaw out the identity of the killer. That is, until she discovers a blizzard…

17
Amish Scarecrow Murders

Book cover of Amish Scarecrow Murders

While Ettie Smith is grappling with a pain in her back, a far more sinister agony sweeps through her peaceful community. Two lives, connected to their serene world, have been reaped in the most horrifying manner, sowing seeds of fear in everyone's heart.
As the mystery grows as tall as…

18
Threadly Secret

Book cover of Threadly Secret: Amish Cozy Mystery
Ettie Smith, an elderly Amish widow known for her keen eye and taste buds, is cordially invited to judge a cookie contest at the local fair—a sweet assignment that soon sours. Amid the patches and stitches of the quilting tent, she stumbles upon a far grimmer sight: a woman, lifeless…

19
Sugar and Spite

Book cover of Sugar and Spite: Amish Cozy Mystery

When the elderly Amish widows, Ettie Smith and her sister, set off to see why candy maker Brunhilde Hoffman was living less of a sweet life and more of a rocky road, they found themselves ensnared in a mystery more complex than a box of assorted chocolates. Brunhilde, the heart…

20
A Puzzling Amish Murder

Book cover of A Puzzling Amish Murder: An Amish Cozy Mystery
Ettie Smith, our favorite octogenarian Amish sleuth, is back, and when she literally stumbles over a dead body, she’s thrust into a new whodunit.
The victim is Deena Brown, an Amish woman with an intriguing backstory. It seems that Deena hadn’t always led a simple Amish life; she used to…

21
Amish Dead & Breakfast

Book cover of Amish Dead & Breakfast: Amish Cozy Mystery

In the heart of Amish country lies a quaint bed and breakfast with secrets thicker than a shoo-fly pie. When elderly Amish widow Ettie Smith and her sister are whisked into the world of wedding catering, little did they know their duties would soon expand to investigating a murder.

Before…

22
Amish Mishaps and Murder

Amish Mishaps and Murder

Sleuth extraordinaire and proud octogenarian, Ettie Smith, springs back into action in book #25 of this delightful Amish mystery series, where furred friends and foul play collide in a tale that's paw-sitively gripping.
Ettie's innocent plan of bestowing her sister, Elsa-May, with an anonymous kitten gift sets off a chain…